● AI Equity Research · Consumer Defensive

Coty Inc. (COTY)

AI stock analysis · Household & Personal Products · Last analyzed Jul 8, 2026

Compass Score

3.0/5

Call

Hold

Price

$2.17

AI Target

$3.13 +44.4%

AI Analyst Summary

Coty is a turnaround story in the Consumer Defensive space that has yet to demonstrate tangible execution, with the bull case resting almost entirely on a deeply discounted forward P/E of 6.2x and a sub-0.2 PEG ratio driven by ambitious recovery estimates. However, the company is currently loss-making, revenue is contracting at -1.3% YoY, and management has missed EPS estimates in all four of the last four quarters — undermining confidence in those forward projections. The key risk is that consensus earnings estimates prove too optimistic, leaving the stock a value trap rather than a recovery play.

Catalysts

A return to profitability in FY2025 driven by cost restructuring and margin recovery in its prestige fragrance and mass beauty segments could validate the low forward P/E and spark analyst upgrades.
Successful execution of its China and emerging market expansion strategy — particularly within its Prestige division — could inflect revenue growth back into positive territory and shift the consensus from Hold toward Buy.
Any debt reduction milestone or improved free cash flow generation in upcoming quarterly reports could alleviate balance sheet concerns and catalyze a re-rating of the stock closer to the $3.13 analyst consensus target.

Risks

Continued EPS misses: With 0 of 4 recent quarters beating estimates, another miss could further erode the already fragile analyst consensus and push the stock below the $2 psychological support level.
Revenue contraction risk: A -1.3% YoY revenue decline could deepen if consumer spending in discretionary personal care weakens, particularly in Europe and North America where Coty has significant exposure.
Balance sheet and leverage risk: Coty carries substantial long-term debt; if profitability recovery stalls, refinancing risk and interest burden could constrain capital allocation and force dilutive equity actions.

Fundamentals

Pe N/A (loss-making) · 1.0/5

No trailing P/E available due to losses. Forward P/E of 6.2x is optically cheap but reflects deep uncertainty around profitability recovery, not a valuation discount from a position of strength.

Peg 0.18 · 5.0/5

PEG of 0.18 is exceptionally low, well below the 1.0 threshold. However, this figure must be interpreted cautiously given current losses and negative revenue growth — it may reflect distorted forward estimates rather than durable growth.

Analyst Rating Hold (3.1) · 3.0/5

Consensus of 3.1 maps to a Hold, with only 1 Buy against 14 Holds and 2 Sells across 14 analysts. Analyst sentiment is tepid with meaningful skepticism from the sell side.

Earnings Trend Negative — revenue declining -1.3% YoY, EPS growth N/A · 1.0/5

Revenue is contracting year-over-year and the company is currently loss-making with no reportable EPS growth. There is no visible earnings acceleration to support a constructive thesis at this stage.

Price Target Beat 0 of 4 quarters beat · 1.0/5

Coty has missed earnings estimates in all 4 of the last 4 quarters. This is a significant red flag for execution quality and management credibility, and raises concerns about the reliability of forward guidance.

Management Weak execution · 1.0/5

A 0-for-4 EPS beat record combined with revenue contraction and loss-making operations signals poor near-term execution. Capital allocation discipline is difficult to assess positively given the persistent earnings misses and muted analyst confidence.

● See the full picture

Get today's top-scored picks, ranked for you.

Compass screens thousands of stocks every morning and hands you a short list of high-conviction picks — scored, explained, and re-ranked to your risk profile.

Start free for 3 days →

No credit card. Then $9/month. Cancel anytime.

How Compass scores stocks

Compass pre-filters thousands of U.S. equities by fundamentals, then an AI analyst scores each finalist 1–5 across six measures — spanning valuation, growth, analyst sentiment, and management quality — into one composite score, refreshed every market morning. Browse all covered stocks →

Not financial advice. Compass is an analytical tool, not a registered investment adviser or broker-dealer. Scores and recommendations are generated by AI, may be inaccurate or out of date, and are not investment, financial, legal, or tax advice. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Do your own research and consult a licensed financial professional. About Compass.